If you are hiring someone to get your business named in ChatGPT, Claude or Perplexity answers, you are buying something nobody can fully show you yet. What you can check is how the agency treats its own site, and whether it will tell you what the work costs before a call. Ten agencies, five checks, one afternoon.
Why the best AEO agency lists all disagree.
Search for the best AEO agencies and you get a page of roundups. Read the bylines. Most are published by an agency selling AEO, and the agency doing the ranking tends to do well in it.
Two examples, both linked from the publisher’s own homepage. Minuttia’s list of the best AEO agencies opens with "1. Minuttia". RevenueZen’s list of the best GEO agencies opens its summary with RevenueZen. Neither is hiding it, and neither is wrong to publish. It is a sensible thing for an agency to write, which is exactly why the page you are reading exists.
The problem is what an assistant does with those pages. Asked who is best at AEO, it finds a dozen lists that each crown a different winner and paraphrases the overlap. You get a blend of self-assessments presented as a consensus.
So this piece does not rank anybody. It runs the same checks on ten agencies and on us, publishes every result, and tells you how each check was run. You will have to make the call. You will be making it on something you can verify.
How we picked the ten.
On 2 November 2026 I searched for the best AEO agencies and for generative engine optimization agencies, and read the roundups that came back. The ten here are the names that kept recurring across those lists, from publishers other than the agency itself.
- NoGood, iPullRank, Omniscient Digital, First Page Sage and Foundation Marketing
- Minuttia, Brainlabs, RevenueZen, Siege Media and WebFX
- And 5Four, run through the same checks, shown separately and not ranked
That is a sample of who is visible when you search, not a census of who is good. Plenty of capable firms do not write listicles and will not appear here. Some of the ten are large SEO and content shops that added AEO to the menu; some lead with it. I have not separated them, because a buyer searching for AEO meets both.
I did not evaluate anyone’s client results. I cannot see them, and neither can you before you sign, which is the point of choosing checks that are public.
The five checks, and why each one.
Each check asks one question: does the agency do on its own site what it would charge you to do on yours? An agency’s site is the one project where nobody else signed off, so it is the cleanest read on its habits.
llms.txt. Does the site serve one at the root? llms.txt is a proposed convention, not a standard, and it is the weakest signal here. It is also the one every AEO pitch mentions, so it is a fair test of whether the pitch is practiced.
Names the AI crawlers. Does robots.txt carry a rule for any of the 8 AI user agents we name on our own site: GPTBot, OAI-SearchBot, ChatGPT-User, ClaudeBot, Claude-SearchBot, PerplexityBot, Google-Extended and Applebot-Extended?
Serves the AI crawlers. Ask for the homepage as GPTBot, ClaudeBot, PerplexityBot and OAI-SearchBot and see what comes back. A robots.txt can say yes while a firewall in front of it says no, and the firewall wins.
FAQPage on the AEO page. Does the page selling AEO carry FAQPage schema? It is the most common structured data recommendation in the field, so the page that sells it is the obvious place to look for it.
A published price. Does the AEO page, or a pricing page it links to, state a number? This is not a technical check. It is the one buyers ask about first and agencies answer last.
The results, agency by agency.
Here is every result. Nothing is scored or weighted; a column is a fact you can re-check with one command.
| Agency | llms.txt | Names AI crawlers | Served to AI crawlers | FAQPage on AEO page | Published price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NoGood | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | No |
| iPullRank | Yes | No | Yes | No | No |
| Omniscient Digital | Yes | No | Yes | No | A floor: from $120,000 a year |
| First Page Sage | No (404) | No | Yes | No | No |
| Foundation Marketing | No (404) | No | Yes, after one 429 | No | No |
| Minuttia | Yes | No | Yes | No | No |
| Brainlabs | No (404) | No | Yes | No | No |
| RevenueZen | Yes | No | Yes | No | $3,000 to $15,000 a month |
| Siege Media | No (404) | No | Yes | Yes | No |
| WebFX | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | $3,000 to $68,250 a month |
| 5Four (us) | Yes | Yes, all 8 | Yes | No AEO page | No AEO price |
Nobody blocks the crawlers, and naming them is not the test.
The headline result is a non-event. All ten agencies let the AI crawlers in. Every robots.txt allows them through the wildcard rule, and every homepage came back with a 200 to all four AI user agents.
One wrinkle. Foundation answered ClaudeBot with a 429, which means too many requests, and then a 200 on an immediate retry. That is a rate limit doing its job, not a block, and I have counted it as a pass. It is still worth knowing that a firewall sits in front of a site and makes its own decisions about bots.
The column where we are the only pass is the one I would weigh least. None of the ten names an AI crawler, and that is fine. A wildcard allow lets GPTBot in just as well as a named rule does. Naming them matters when you want different rules for different bots, or when you want a written record that the choice was deliberate.
So do not hire us, or rule anybody out, on that column. It is in the table because I said I would run the same checks on everyone, us included, and dropping the one we win would be its own kind of spin.
The one robots.txt that blocks anything outright is WebFX’s, and the agent it blocks is ia_archiver, the Internet Archive. That is a choice about being archived, not about being quoted.
The llms.txt split, and what it tells you.
Six of the ten serve an llms.txt. Four return a 404: First Page Sage, Foundation, Brainlabs and Siege Media. All four of those publish about generative or answer engine optimization, and Siege links a GEO book from its homepage.
I would not read that as negligence. No engine has committed to reading llms.txt, which is the honest position and the one we take in our own piece on it. An agency that has looked at the evidence and decided not to bother is making a defensible call.
What it does tell you is how the agency will talk to you about it. If an agency without one pitches it to you as essential, the pitch and the practice disagree. If an agency with one sells it as the thing that gets you cited, it is overselling something nobody can measure.
The quality of the six varies more than the count suggests. Some are a short summary with a few links. Some run to hundreds of lines. Length is not the test; whether the first paragraph says plainly who the company is and who it serves is. Most of the six do that well, which is more than most company websites manage on their homepage.
Who publishes a price, and what it buys.
Three of the ten state a number. Two publish monthly prices, and one publishes a floor. The other seven ask you to book a call.
RevenueZen lists 6 plans, from $3,000 to $15,000 a month. Their own wording says no long-term commitment is required, and 6- and 12-month contracts are offered at a discount. The plan they call a full GEO program, a quarterly deep audit plus citation optimization, starts at the $10,000 Scale plan. The cheaper plans include AI brand monitoring and topic research rather than the full program.
WebFX lists 8 tiers, priced from $3,000 to $68,250 a month on a 6-month commitment, with the top tier by quote. The entry tier tracks 50 prompts across 10 AI engines. Weekly re-checks of those prompts cost $150 a month per 50 prompts, and daily re-checks $850.
Omniscient Digital states that full-service engagements start at $120,000 a year. That is a floor rather than a price list, and it tells you plainly who the firm is built for.
A published price is not the same as a good price. It is a sign the agency has standardized the work enough to say what it costs, and it saves you a sales call to find out you are out of range. That is worth something on its own.
A shortlist, by what you need.
I cannot tell you who does the best work, so this is sorted by fit, using each agency’s own description of itself and its own published terms. Treat it as where to start your calls, not where to end them.
- You are a B2B software company with a budget past six figures a year. Omniscient Digital describes itself as an organic growth agency for B2B software companies, covering SEO, AEO, content and digital PR, and its stated floor matches that.
- You want a price before a call and no long contract. RevenueZen publishes six monthly plans and says no long-term commitment is required.
- You want AI visibility measured across many engines, at volume. WebFX prices prompt tracking across 10 AI engines into every tier and sells more frequent re-checks as an add-on.
- You are an enterprise with a large existing SEO program. iPullRank describes itself as an enterprise SEO, content strategy and AI Search agency.
- You are a growth-stage B2B, SaaS or ecommerce brand. NoGood describes itself as a growth marketing agency specializing in those three, and its AEO page practices the FAQ markup it sells.
First Page Sage, Foundation, Minuttia, Brainlabs and Siege Media are left off this list for one reason: none of them publishes a price or a stated focus specific enough for me to sort them on. That says nothing about their work. Ask each the questions in section ten.
Where 5Four fits, and where we lose.
We are a design and build studio. AEO at 5Four is built into the site we make: the structure, the schema, the glossary, the crawler rules and the build checks described in how to get your site cited by AI assistants. It is not sold as a standalone retainer.
Now the part a piece like this usually leaves out. On the things most of these agencies sell, they beat us.
- Measurement. WebFX and RevenueZen sell prompt tracking and citation monitoring across several AI engines. We do not run that as a service. If you need a monthly number for how often you are named in answers, hire one of them.
- Off-site work. Being cited depends heavily on how often you are described consistently on sites you do not control. Digital PR and content distribution are named services at Omniscient and elsewhere. We do not sell either.
- A published AEO price. Three of the ten tell you what AEO costs. We do not, because it is part of a build rather than a line of its own. That is a reason, and it is still a call you have to book to get the number.
- Results. Our own site went live on 28 October 2026. We have no citation count to show you yet, and we will not invent one.
Where we fit is the site itself. If your problem is that the pages are not built to be quoted, with no answer up front, no addressable sections, markup that disagrees with the page, that is structural work and it is what we do. Once the site is right, the Run plans keep it right. They are hosting and care, not an AEO retainer, and I would not sell them as one.
A sensible pairing for a lot of companies is a studio to fix the site and a measurement-led agency to track and push. Those are different jobs.
What to ask any AEO agency before you sign.
The checks above take a minute each and you can run them on any agency, including ones not on this page. Then ask these on the call.
- What exactly will you measure, on which engines, and how often? Ask to see a real report, with the client name hidden.
- How do you separate what you did from what would have happened anyway? Citations move without anyone touching the site.
- What do you change on my site, and what happens off it? Get both lists in writing.
- Who owns the content, the tracking setup and the prompts list when we stop?
- What is the minimum term, and what does leaving cost?
- Does your own site do what you are recommending for mine? Run the five checks before the call and ask about any gap.
The first two are blockers. An agency that cannot say what it measures, or claims every movement as its own, is selling you a number it cannot defend. The answer you want is a stated method and an admission of what it cannot attribute.
How we checked, and what we could not verify.
Every check was run on 2 November 2026 from one machine with curl, and every price was read off the agency’s own page and quoted word for word in the research file that sits beside this post. The commands are in that file, so the table can be re-run on any date.
The crawler check is a user-agent test, not a crawler test. The requests came from our machine carrying GPTBot’s or ClaudeBot’s name, not from those companies’ published address ranges. A firewall that verifies real crawler addresses can treat the real crawler differently, in either direction.
The FAQPage check looks at one page per agency, the page selling AEO or GEO. An agency may carry the markup elsewhere and fail this column. Where I could not find a dedicated page, I used the closest service page linked from the homepage.
And the limit that matters most: none of this measures whether an agency gets its clients cited. That is the thing you are buying, and it is not public for anyone, us included. These checks tell you about habits and honesty. Prices move, and this table is true on the day in its caption.
I will re-run it each quarter and update the date in the caption. If an agency here thinks a row is wrong, the command that produced it is in the research file, and I will correct it.
The structural side of this, the part that lives on your own site, is written up in full in how to get your site cited by AI assistants. It is the method we run on every client build.
Related: Answer Engine Optimization in the glossary, what llms.txt is worth, every comparison we have published.



